Friday, 30 October 2026

Getting Mysterious with Jon Matthew Farber

The Fourth Black Beacon Book of Mystery will be released on the 23rd of November, but the Kindle version is available for pre-order today at just $1.99 instead of $3.99 and the Goodreads listing is up. To get you in the mood for mystery, we’ve interviewed our contributing authors. Are you keen to peer into their minds—a complex world of clues, red herrings, and puzzling plots? This volume of mysteries will be as challenging as ever, but our cast of amateur sleuths, private investigators, and police inspectors will leave no stone unturned!

Hi Jon,

What is it about the genre of mystery that gets the cogs turning in your head?

I enjoy puzzles. I’m an avid bridge and chess player, and my favourite mysteries are fair-play ones, where I can piece the clues together and solve the case. That having been said, I also appreciate well-constructed stories where I’m unsuccessful at matching the detective’s skill.

What ingredients are needed for a great fair-play mystery in which the reader can try to solve the puzzle before all is revealed?

First off, the murder must be plausible. For example, if needed, I can accept the murderer using a very powerful magnet, as long as the groundwork is laid out for it in in the story. However, if the magnet is in the murderer’s shoe... Second, I don’t want what I call Watson clues. These are clues so obvious that even Watson could figure them out. An example of one I came across is the following. The murderer had to break a window in order to commit their crime. The next day, one of the suspects is described as having multiple bandages on their hand, as if they had cut it on glass. Third, the clue must be well hidden, but solvable without arcane knowledge. If a victim leaves a dying message of a word which appears to be in English but leads nowhere, because it is actually Latin, that’s unfair because most of us aren’t fluent in the language. However, if we have been previously told that the victim was a professor of Latin, then I feel the reader can take full credit for remembering and using that fact. Indeed, nowadays, one can take extra credit by then going on the Internet to look up the translation (this is not cheating), and then using that information to reach the ultimate solution.

What are your protagonist’s strengths and weaknesses, trademark quirks, and bad habits?

Professor Simon has been seen multiple times, including in The Third Black Beacon Book of Mystery. His strength is obviously his intelligence. In the short story format, there isn’t much time to deal with weaknesses or bad habits, so I haven’t done that yet, but this could be interesting to explore in the future. Hubris would be an obvious weakness, but trite; I’m more intrigued by a case he misses solving (at first) because of overthinking. One quirk of his is that he delivers formal lectures, including dropping most contractions, when he summarizes a case. Another, not exactly a quirk, is something he would probably not like to admit to himself, as it isn’t congruent with his self-view as a man of logic. He enjoys acting, often carrying out improvisational roles to entice confessions from killers, as he does in the upcoming anthology.

A great mystery needs a killer plot and likeable—or despicable—characters, but setting and atmosphere are also key. What are your favourite settings for a really mysterious atmosphere?

I focus more on the concept of mystery as a puzzle, rather than something spooky or scary. As such, I’m very fond of locked rooms / impossible crimes.

What’s the most mysterious place you’ve ever been?

The Winchester Mystery House in California. This has hundreds of rooms (not all accessible on the tour), with numerous curiosities, and is an architectural mish-mash.

What was the last mystery you read?

The Impossible Fortune by Richard Osman. Unlike the other books in the Thursday Murder Club Series, this was not a solvable whodunit. However, the plot, while contrived, was acceptable, the pacing excellent and never lagging, it was sprinkled with humour, and the characters are very well drawn. I am very fond of this series and recommend it highly.

What’s one type of mystery you’ve been meaning to write but haven’t got around to
yet—locked room, closed circle, police procedural, cold case, historical mystery, art theft?

As I assume is true for many authors, I would like to write a Holmes story (but see below). I did write a parody in the now defunct Mystery Magazine, but I don’t count that.

What are you working on now?

Actually, nothing. Apart from my fair-play mystery novel Do Not Resuscitate (co-written with Danieal Reinharth), I only write short stories, around three per year. When an idea for a story strikes me, I work it out in my head for a few days, then jot down a first draft. After that, it goes into hibernation until I feel ready to edit it. At the present time, I have three such stories; two are Professor Simon dying message ones (as in the upcoming anthology) which may show up in future Black Beacon Books titles, and the other is the Holmes story hinted at above.

Where can we find you online?

You can’t. I don’t have a personal web page. You could find some of my older medical blogs at allpediatrics.com, and another Professor Simon story at https://theyardcrimeblog.com/2025/12/04/piece-offering-mystery-fiction/

Thanks for playing along!

No comments:

Post a Comment