Tuesday, 17 November 2026

Getting Mysterious with S. B. Watson

The Fourth Black Beacon Book of Mystery will be released on the 23rd of November, but the Kindle version is available for pre-order today at just $1.99 instead of $3.99 and the Goodreads listing is up. To get you in the mood for mystery, we’ve interviewed our contributing authors. Are you keen to peer into their minds—a complex world of clues, red herrings, and puzzling plots? This volume of mysteries will be as challenging as ever, but our cast of amateur sleuths, private investigators, and police inspectors will leave no stone unturned!

Hi S.B.,

What is it about the genre of mystery that gets the cogs turning in your head?

I think there’s two answers to this, one from the reader’s point of view, and one from the writer’s. As a reader, I find myself continually drawn towards the gothic elements of a good classic mystery. Hardboiled, Noir, Psychological, all these genres are good, but the cozy-murder-in-the-English-country-village has a bit more of the good old, Victorian sewing-a-fingernail-necklace-with-corpse-hair factor hidden beneath the polite veneer. I find there’s a lot of horror and gruesomeness quietly baked into the Golden Age stories, and that keeps me coming back.

I recently broke my right wrist, and so last month I had a LOT of free time, which I split between watching movies and reading. I found that after a few mystery novels, I’d switch to some other genre, but after a single non-mystery I’d feel the urge to return, because I was missing the gothic spooky factor—the mysteriousness. (Side note, the Japanese Shin Honkaku writers have an uncanny knack for grabbing this gothic vibe and mixing it with extremely well-crafted puzzles.)

As a writer, the craft of constructing a robust little puzzle that also operates as a functional, persuasive story is addictive. I write some horror, some sci-fi, some fantasy, as well, but to me there’s no experience quite as satisfying as weaving a story full of clues, puzzle-threads, and grotesque imagery. 

Let’s be real, here, most mysteries are just morbid fantasies—That’s both what I read for, and write towards.

What ingredients are needed for a great fair-play mystery in which the reader can try to solve the puzzle before all is revealed?

Well, first off, fair-play requires an actual logical progression of clues that cover, if not everything, most everything involved in the mechanism of the mystery. That sounds simple, but what it actually means is the story has to lay the solution under the readers’ noses, for anyone to see if they look in the right places. Now, you can’t just put the solution there, and hope nobody spots it—laying those clues requires cunning writing and misdirection, as well as some understanding of what readers actually will notice. You want them to catch most of the clues, and slightly remember them, so that when you reveal the solution they have a facepalm moment at the end, rather than headscratching confusion.

Other ingredients? A good murder or theft or crime. It doesn’t have to be of the Impossible Genre, but I find that helps, because it allows the crime itself to add to the atmosphere of the story, instead of just being the stock sin that kicks off the plot.

Sleuth is important too, but I find not as much as the actual mystery… And that comes from someone who loves most of their protagonists, so…

What are your protagonist’s strengths and weaknesses, trademark quirks, and bad habits?

“Benediction of Stone” is one of my Norman Saga stories, set in the cusp between the Early and Late Middle Ages, before Normandy invaded Britain. Most of the Norman Saga follows a half-Jewish thief named Galswinth and the revolving band of ruffians that work with her. “Godbrillan’s Pit,” published in Dragon Soul Press’s “Crimewave” anthology, introduced Fildirado Fumagalli, a deceptively brilliant, bumbling papal legate sent from Rome to root out the heretical trade of false relics (although it’s just as likely he was sent away to get him out of the pope’s hair).

In “Benediction of Stone,” Fumigalli is back—along with his personal clerk, a fiery-haired subdeacon, Attaviano Fiaccus. Taking a break in his endless pursuit of Galswinth, the legate pauses to authenticate a miracle at a local church, where a statue of Mary is said to have animated and blessed the congregation, curing not one, but two cripples.

The Norman Saga stories are to date my favorite creations, although they are also some of my oddest, full of off-balance characters. Fumagalli is no exception. As far as strengths, weaknesses, quirks, and bad habits go? He’s persistent, indomitable, incorruptible, and incorrigible. His boundless energy and curiosity often are used against him. His eye for detail is not always flawless (remember, I’ve written him from both sides, some stories from the viewpoint of the villains’, and others from the legate’s), and is occasionally clouded by his enthusiasm. He is known for fast, jerky movements and motions, and has a peculiar physicality about him. He loves food, although he (purportedly) despises gluttony. Probably his worst habit is telling the least acceptable truths at the worst times—rumored to be part of the reason the pope "banished" him to Normandy in the first place.

A great mystery needs a killer plot and likeable—or despicable—characters, but setting and atmosphere are also key. What are your favourite settings for a really mysterious atmosphere?

As you say, atmosphere is key. I’m not sure that any one setting really is necessary to achieve this… I think the right atmosphere can be attained with any setting. That being said, some settings require more work to get the right feel. In general, I’d say settings that by their nature include decades of cultural cues and connotations are very helpful. Cruise ships, jungle hospitals, ruined mansions, too-sleepy country villages, museums, British India, French Polynesia, remote radar stations, mountain monasteries, submarines, rural village temples, forgotten shrines, clockmakers’ workshops, old movie theatres, radio stations, catacombs and sewer complexes, retrofitted castles, ancient castles, sages’ studies, libraries…

What’s the most mysterious place you’ve ever been?


Frankly, I don’t usually feel that I’m in a mysterious place when I’m there. That sort of atmosphere is usually fake. That being said, there are a handful of places I’ve been that stand out. Christmas Valley, a high desert in Eastern Oregon—very otherworldly, but it may be more spooky than mysterious. Any of the Oregon Coast lighthouses, most of which are purported to be haunted. In Seoul, all the shrines, temples, and historic sites peppered through the city are little pockets of mystery surrounded by cyberpunk daily life.

Figure 1 - I, my wife, and our second daughter by Yauqina Bay Lighthouse... Haunted.
Figure 2 – Hiking Fort Rock, in Christmas Valley, with my eldest son years ago. ‘Haunted’ by UFOs, apparently.
Figure 3 – Royal Tombs of the Joseon Dynasty, Seoul, South Korea. Very tranquil, and mysterious, place. Should be haunted!

What was the last mystery you read?

The last mystery I read was “The Devotion of Suspect X” by Keigo Higashino! While not a Locked-Room, I think you’d have to be a Locked-Room writer to construct this plot. It was brilliant.

What’s one type of mystery you’ve been meaning to write but haven’t got around to yet—locked room, closed circle, police procedural, cold case, historical mystery, art theft?

I’m not really sure… Because I write short stories, I have the luxury of being able to jump genres/styles relatively quickly. A lot of the genres I wanted to write, I have. Maybe Romance-Mystery… Sounds a bit appalling, but might be a fun challenge.

What are you working on now?

A vampire-themed impossible murder, complete with staking dead bodies, staking live bodies, plenty of occult spookiness, and a clever Roma detective. After that, I’m planning on writing another Norman Saga story, which may be my most intricate, complex one yet. One thing that’s unusual about the Norman Saga stories is that, because most of them are told from the criminals’ points of view, many of them could be considered Reverse Locked Rooms, where we follow the villains intentionally creating a
falsity to look like a miracle. Some are heist stories, and some have been more drama-oriented. The next story I have in mind will attempt to do all three of these things, at the same time… We’ll see.

Where can we find you online?

SBWatson.com, on X, on Facebook, on Instagram!

Thanks for playing along!

No comments:

Post a Comment